July 2002

"Pictures Tell The Story" was the logo on the awning of Ernst Wither's photo studio in Memphis for fifty years. Had he confined his practice to weddings and funerals, debutante balls, church leaders and Sunday School classes, he would be forgotten. But against all odds Withers became one of the premier African-American photojournalists of the 20th century, on a par with colleagues Frederick Roberts and Gordon Parks.

Wither's own story, untold in the pictures, is also extraordinary: a self-made man, he asserted himself despite intense racial hatred and survived by extraordinary perseverance and an ironic outlook without ever becoming bitter.



When Withers was born in 1922 to a modest family, the fifth of six children, the black and white communities of Memphis might as well have lived on different planets. For ambitious young African-Americans opportunities were scarce. Withers, who had already lost his mother by age nine, became the photographer for his high school and covered baseball games and parties. To complement his action shots he started posing players after the games. On Sundays he and his brother were back at the ball field, hawking prints for a dollar.

Photography would have remained a sideline had Withers not volunteered for military service at the outbreak of World War II: he received the formal training that he could not otherwise afford at an Army School in Camp Sutton, North Carolina, learning darkroom skills and the use of large-format cameras. He was then sent to the Pacific where military service was, for many black and white soldiers, their first real contact with men their age but of a different race. For Withers it was a positive and powerful experience.

After the war and years of developing and printing at the kitchen sink with his wife Dorothy Curry, Withers and his brother used the money from the G.I. bill as a downpayment on a building and set up a studio where Withers could do portraits in a controlled setting and have a real darkroom.

As of the late 1940s, Memphis saw the emergence of rock'n'roll out of the gospel, folk and rhythm-and-blues culture of the Mississippi Delta. Withers who was originally one of the first African-American policemen in the country (before being unjustly thrown off the force) and was a friend to the deejay Nat Dee Williams, had access to the night-club scene and to the most prominent musicians: Aretha Franklin, Elvis Presley, B.B. King, Ike and Tina Turner, Isaac Hayes, Howlin' Wolf and Muddy Waters. He also made numerous portraits of the teams in the Negro Baseball League and individual portraits of Jackie Robinson and Willie Mays But above all, and at great personal risk, he became involved in the Civil Rights Movement.

In a heart-wrenching sequence of loss done just after Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr, was assassinated, Withers used a style completely different from his usual warm and involved approach: in almost forensic style he minutely documented every place, ,object and person related to Dr. King's death: the bathroom window from which James Earl Ray had fired the fatal shot; his dingy motel room; the last waitress to have served King a meal; King's open briefcase on his last night's bed with neatly folded pajamas and a stack of newspapers with an image of his smiling face.

And as we look on, Withers' previous images, full of life and hope, images of what could have been, of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., marching, saluting, smiling, relaxing on his bed after a demonstration, come back to haunt us.

In 1955 Withers had self-published and distributed for a dollar a thirty-picture pamphlet on the Emmett Till murder trial, a reproach in words and pictures of the criminal justice system as applied to African-Americans. He wrote: "We are not only depicting the plight of an individual Negro but rather of life as it affects all Negroes in the United States.” This sentence could aptly describe all of Wither's remarkable life and work.

-- Carole Naggar


Gallery 292
120 Wooster Street
New York city
Until August 3rd
www.gallery292.com

Ernest Withers: The Memphis Blues Again ,Viking Studio, 2001